Welcome to “Good Mythical”– Hey! “Check your voicemail.” We have a voicemail. Let’s check it. Man: Hey, what’s going on, everybody? So, uh, which one of you guys wants to get slapped with a rubber chicken now or later? Take your time. All right, have a nice day. Bye-bye. The ol’ slap with a rubber chicken offer. Now or later, though. We get those all the time, but not with the now-or-later option. Is neither one of us an option? Neither one of us. I’m looking around to make sure somebody doesn’t have a rubber chicken. – Oh, no. – Good. They don’t. – That would’ve required– – We disallowed those. Remember when we got our old studio decorated for a shoot, and then that really became a decoration for the studio? And there was a rubber chicken on the shelf, and I was like– No, it was on the fridge. It was on the fridge handle. And we didn’t want it because rubber chickens are too cliché comedy. But then, not too long ago, we played a game, and you insisted on us using rubber chickens as the buzzer. But we didn’t do it, did we? – We did. – Oh. – I regretted it instantly. – Gosh. Yeah, I had a lapse in judgment. That’s why you’re here. What happened? So what we have is we have six different rounds here. We’re gonna move through this pretty quickly. We have mixed– well, we didn’t mix– the Mythical crew has mixed two actual Jell-O pudding brand puddings together. Oh. Oh! Oh, now you understand how this game works? They told me and I was like, “This is gonna be easy. Just guessing Jell-O flavors?” – No. – They mixed two! And they have all these different flavor flags over here. Flavorflag.com– don’t go there. I don’t know what it is. It’s just, whenever I say two words like that together, I feel like it should be a website. Flavorflag.net– go there. And you assume it’s a bad website. Naughty. And we’re gonna try to guess what two flavors have been combined. Now, I– I’m a pudding lover. – If you lose this– – Look. But listen. You’re such a pudding man. You’re a pudding master. – The only pudding– – Don’t let me beat you, man. Thank you. Thank you, but the only pudding that I eat is chocolate, vanilla, and if I run across some peanut butter. I know one of the flavors already. Mmm. I know this right off the bat. Yeah, well, one of them. What’s the other one? Hold on. Definitely– I’m not showing mine to you. That’s one of them. This is definitely one of them. – Um, man. – And… – Um… – Um… I don’t know, man. And I know– this is the other one. Right. Don’t– don’t look at my answers now. Okay, that’s what I got. Oh, we got the same answers. – Oh, we have the same– – Butterscotch and coconut cream. – Are we right? Oh, they don’t tell us. – We don’t know. Okay, so now we’ll move that over. – We bring in the next one. – Bring in the next one. Don’t look at our monitor over there to cheat. I didn’t. I don’t cheat, Link. I’m not a cheater. You don’t admit to cheating. Is this cream? Mm. Mm! It’s interesting. Eating pudding is fun. It’s a lifestyle. Is that your suggested slogan? – Eating pudding is fun. – Jell-O pudding– Both: It’s a lifestyle. – I don’t think that would work. – It gets better the more I eat. Well, I know one. I know one, too. The one that I know right off the bat is that one. This is tough, man, but… This one is tough. I don’t know. They could be– I’m gonna guess that it’s this based on color. So I said vanilla pistachio. I said pistachio and tapioca. – Ooh, “tapi-yoke.” – I scared you, didn’t I? – You may be right. – I think vanilla’s in there. I think you’re right. This one’s pink. ( imitating Church Lady ) Isn’t this one special? – Fruity. – Did you know there were so many flavors of pudding? – No. – What are they doing over there at Jell-O? They got somebody just coming up with different flavors. Who would have thought? So that’s pretty clear, but… Oh, oh. Oh, this is tough. – This is difficult. – This is tough because it– The second component is pretty difficult here. So I’m either down to this… – The initial one is really obvious. – Or this. I’m trying to figure out between these two. Mythical Beasts, send me your answer. Which one is it? – Um. – I don’t know. I’m at a little bit of a loss, but I’m going with that. – All right– – Cheesecake and strawberry? I went with strawberry and banana cream. I almost did that, but I don’t like banana that much, so– – I thought that you would– – I coulda– I can hone in on the thing I don’t like. You’ve got great banana radar. Right. “Banay-dar,” they call it. Max Banadar. You just spouted off a random guy that we used to work with– his name. – Okay. – That was a shout out. – Okay, there’s an obvious component. – Ooh, that’s good. – Link: Very good. – Rhett: Mmm, man. I’m just glad none of these flags say “coyote piss” on them. ‘Cause halfway through this game, you better believe I looked. Yeah, it’s funny. I always eat things on this show with just a sense of– – Trepidation. – …trepidation. There’s no trepidation now. I’ve let my guard down. But what is the other flavor there? I got it. All right, you ready? I went with vanilla and Oreo. – Oreo… – I think you’re right. – …and tapioca. – Tapioca. I– – Ooh. – There’s no switchies in this one. I think you might be the pudding master, Link. Ooh, what’s this, curry? Little… It’s probably not curry. Ugh. This one tastes like cleaner. Like, literally, like… I don’t feel like I need more than one. Like sop this on your toilet. – Link: Ugh. – Yeah. Yeah, pumpkin spice and lemon. Same for me. – That’s gross. – Okay, and finally, What’s this one gonna be? Move this here. Oh. Ooh, ooh! That is a nice experience right there. And I’m gonna– I’m gonna highly recommend that, guys. You think you know what it is? Um, you said chocolate? I know you were thinking this is a good combo. I think that the chocolate– I don’t think chocolate’s in there. I think you’re getting red velvet taste as chocolate. So what did you say it was? I mean, cheesecake, ’cause that’s all– I have chocolate and caramel left. I don’t think it’s either one of those. All right, that’s our guesses. Tell us what we did. Okay, pudding number one is chocolate– Oh, sorry. That’s wrong. “Sorry, that’s wrong.” Did you say “sarong”? Um, it starts with a “C”. Coconut cream and butterscotch. – Yes! – Yep. So you both got that correct. Oh, we both got it right. Pudding number two is banana cream and pistachio. Ooh, you were right, huh? No, you both thought pistachio. I said tapioca and pistachio. So we both get one point for that. – There’s banana in this? – Yes. I taste it now. It’s so obvious. So pudding number three is strawberry and vanilla. Strawberry and vanilla. And you said strawberry and cheesecake. I knew it was subtle. Didn’t get that one. – You didn’t either, right? – Nope. Pudding number four is Oreo cookies ‘n creme and tapioca. – I got that one. – You got another one right. Okay, so Link just went up a point. – Right? – Correct. – Yes. – Okay. All right. Pumpkin spice and lemon we agreed on. Are we right? Yep, you are right on that one. Ooh, so it comes down to the very end, Link. No, I’m ahead by one. You were down by one, right, yeah, but– – No, I’m ahead by one. – I mean, you’re up by one. You can’t even use language of me winning. – Yeah– – It doesn’t exist in your mind. I haven’t said it in so long, my brain won’t let my mouth say it. Is it chocolate and red velvet? It’s red velvet and cheesecake. Which is what I said! We tied! Dang it! Man, I wanted you to win. I did. I wanted you to take all the puddings and celebrate. I think the best combination we found– This was– I don’t know– No, that had banana. I didn’t like it. It was this red velvet and whatever you said it was. Cheesecake. That’s a good one. This red velvet cheesecake, that’s what you should order at a Cheesecake Factory.