– [Rhett] Today, the peanut butter boys – [Rhett] take a trip to heaven. – [Link] Let’s talk about that ((Intro Music)) – [Link] Good Mythical Morning. – [Rhett] Every once in a while, – [Rhett] it’s important to take time – [Rhett] to reflect on just – [Rhett] how blessed we are. – [Link] Yes. And today is definitely – [Link] one of those days. – [Link] Honestly, I don’t want to even – [Link] talk any longer. – [Link] I want to get into it. – [Link] Almost don’t even want to acknowledge – [Link] this amazing Halloween set. – [Rhett] What? ((Screams)) – [Link] You scared me, dude. – [Rhett] I’m so scared of pumpkins. – [Rhett] Anything from the gourd family. ((Screams)) – [Rhett] There’s one. – [Link] Stop it. – [Rhett] Sorry. – [Link] Okay. ((Laughing)) – [Link] It’s time for – [Link] Gut Check: Reese’s Edition. – [Link] Dude, you got me all – [Link] You got me all spiked up. – [Rhett] Sorry, man. – [Stevie] Peanut butter boys, – [Stevie] today you get to continue – [Stevie] those spirited debates – [Stevie] about the best proportion of – [Stevie] peanut butter to chocolate. – [Stevie] While you Gut Check – [Stevie] your very favorite Reese’s. – [Stevie] The Mythical Crew has acquired – [Stevie] all of the available Reese’s candy varieties, – [Stevie] meaning no Reese’s snack products – [Stevie] and no seasonal products. – [Stevie] For a whopping total of – [Stevie] 30 Reese’s varieties – [Stevie] that you will try today. – [Stevie] And after you try each one, – [Stevie] you’ll give it a score of 1 to 100 – [Stevie] based on your gut reaction. – [Link] 1 to 100. Thank you for – [Link] yet another helpful scoring aid. – [Link] The ultimate peanut butter boy – [Link] scoring chart. – [Rhett] Yeah, and thank you for – [Rhett] giving me one of Link’s old ones. – [Link] We typically sign those, – [Link] and give them away – [Link] at the Mythical Society. – [Rhett] This is a bit of an upgrade – [Rhett] from just a piece of cardboard – [Rhett] with Sharpie on it. – [Stevie] So today we felt that – [Stevie] the palate cleansers were extra important – [Stevie] because you don’t know what’s going to – [Stevie] cut through that peanut butter. – [Stevie] So you have some options. – [Stevie] You have some white bread – [Stevie] because of course. – [Stevie] You also have some milk – [Stevie] and you have some seltzer water. – [Stevie] So I guess you’ll discover as we go – [Stevie] throughout this thing – [Stevie] what’s going to help you the most, – [Stevie] because you’re going to be – [Stevie] consuming a lot of peanut butter today. – [Stevie] And – [Link] Yes, Lord. – [Stevie] Thank you. – [Link] I will call you Lord, today. – [Stevie] You know I like it – [Stevie] when you call me, Lord. – [Stevie] We’re going to kick it off – [Stevie] with our Regular Sized Cup category, – [Stevie] starting with – [Stevie] the original Milk Chocolate – [Stevie] peanut butter cups. – [Link] Oh, it’s got a nice ridge on it. – [Rhett] I mean, that’s almost a perfect candy. – [Rhett] 97. – [Link] You know what? – [Link] I think there’s plenty versions – [Link] that are better than this. – [Link] I’m going to give it – [Link] an 80 – [Stevie] Now, I’m not going to say Reese’s – [Stevie] every single time we go through this. – [Stevie] So I’m just going to go with – [Stevie] Creamy Milk Chocolate. – [Link] Creamy Milk Chocolate. – [Rhett] That’s a thing? – [Link] I didn’t know that was a thing – [Link] it puts a little bit more emphasis – [Link] on the peanut butter. – [Rhett] It is smooth. – [Rhett] It kind of caught me off guard, – [Rhett] to be honest with you. – [Link] 75. – [Rhett] I agree. I don’t think – [Rhett] it’s quite as good as the orig. – [Rhett] it still very good. – [Rhett] 90 – [Stevie] Crunchy Milk Chocolate. – [Link] What? – [Rhett] Do you know about this? – [Link] Well, the peanut butter is crunchy, – [Link] not the milk chocolate. – [Link] I’m not much of a – [Link] crunchy peanut butter, man. – [Rhett] The thing I don’t like – [Rhett] about crunchy peanut butter – [Rhett] is that you taste the peanuts, – [Rhett] the whole peanut changes – [Rhett] the overall taste of the peanut butter. – [Rhett] So I like the experience of the crunch. – [Rhett] Don’t like the taste as much. – [Rhett] 84. – [Link] I’m going to give it an 80. – [Link] Tied with the original. – [Stevie] Chocolate Lovers Milk Chocolate – [Link] What could that mean? – [Link] Chocolate lovers? – [Link] Maybe it’s like – [Link] a higher end milk chocolate. – [Rhett] I think the chocolate’s – [Rhett] trying too hard in this one. – [Link] I do too. Yes. – [Link] 61. – [Rhett] It’s still very tasty. – [Rhett] 78. – [Stevie] White Creme. – [Rhett] That was my nickname in high school. – [Stevie] I was waiting for it. – [Rhett] Sometimes I just feel obligated. – [Rhett] Not a huge fan of white chocolate. – [Rhett] 48. – [Link] It’s not bad, but it’s not good. – [Link] I give it a 50. – [Stevie] Plant Based Oat Chocolate Confection. – [Rhett] What? – [Rhett] This feels like a joke. – [Link] And what happened to it? – [Rhett] It got plant based. – [Link] It’s hard. – [Rhett] You sure this is real? – [Link] It’s crisp and powdery inside. – [Rhett] It tastes like a really old Reese’s – [Rhett] like this would be from the, – [Rhett] if we were tasting expired Reese’s – [Rhett] from the 60’s – [Link] Yeah. – [Link] Just do without. – [Rhett] That’s a 12. – [Link] I’ll give it a 1 – [Stevie] Organic Milk Chocolate. – [Rhett] Yeah I need to get my – [Rhett] I need to wash my mouth out. – [Link] I need to wash my mouth out. – [Rhett] Wash my mouth out with milk. – [Link] Organic, so this is just – [Link] for your conscience. – [Rhett] There is a difference in taste. – [Rhett] Completely different. – [Link] I know. I’m surprised. – [Rhett] I think I actively, slightly dislike it. – [Rhett] 49. – [Link] 24. – [Stevie] Organic Dark Chocolate. – [Rhett] Okay – [Link] Is this better? – [Rhett] It’s harder. – [Link] Why is it so hard? – [Rhett] Because it’s dark. – [Rhett] It doesn’t have the – [Link] Other organic was hard. – [Rhett] Not that hard. – [Rhett] It doesn’t have the nasty chocolate taste. – [Rhett] This just tastes like – [Rhett] dark chocolate with peanut butter. – [Link] I can almost not taste – [Rhett] Which I enjoy on my own, – [Rhett] but I don’t like – [Rhett] in the Reese’s combination as much. – [Link] I’m not getting – [Link] enough peanut butter here. – [Rhett] 54. – [Link] 30. – [Stevie] And that concludes – [Stevie] the regular sized category. – [Stevie] Up next are Big Cups – [Rhett] Big boys – [Stevie] Starting with – [Stevie] Big Cup Milk Chocolate – [Stevie] peanut butter cups. – [Link] I’ve always been afraid of these. – [Link] They come on so strong and tall. – [Link] Okay. – [Link] See, now at least – [Link] we’re back to softness. – [Rhett] Everything’s right in the world again. – [Rhett] And I really love the peanut butter – [Rhett] in these things. – [Rhett] I mean, this is almost perfect for me. – [Rhett] This is just the regular stuff – [Rhett] with a different ratio. – [Link] Like twice as much peanut butter – [Link] to chocolate, but chocolate is – [Link] chocolate is the only thing that can – [Link] outdo peanut butter flavor – [Rhett] 93 – [Rhett] Very good, candy. – [Link] I am not on the – [Link] peanut butter over the top train. – [Link] It’s still great but – [Link] 65. – [Stevie] Big Cup with Reese’s Puffs – [Stevie] Cereal Milk Chocolate. – [Link] This is something. – [Link] I want to look at it. – [Link] I don’t see any in there. – [Rhett] You’ll taste it. – [Rhett] Now, that’s pretty good. – [Link] There’s not that many – [Link] of the cereal – [Rhett] Because you get a crunch. – [Rhett] You get a crunch without – [Rhett] changing the taste of – [Rhett] the peanut butter too much – [Rhett] because the cereal already – [Rhett] tastes like the peanut butter. – [Rhett] It seems a little gimmicky, though. – [Link] I like it better than the Big Cup. – [Rhett] 92. – [Link] Yeah. I’m gonna give it – [Link] a 77. – [Stevie] Big Cup with Pretzels. – [Link] Oh, Lord. – [Link] Don’t. Ain’t no way. – [Link] The salty. – [Rhett] You don’t taste much – [Rhett] of the original pretzel. – [Rhett] It’s more just the crunch. – [Link] The salt kind of enhances – [Link] the the flavor of the peanut butter. – [Link] And I don’t actually taste pretzels. – [Rhett] Yeah, because it’s overwhelmed – [Rhett] by the chocolate – [Rhett] and the peanut butter. – [Link] At all. Wow. – [Rhett] 88. That’s better – [Rhett] than I thought was going to be. – [Link] I got to take it back. – [Link] Yeah, this is, freaking, a surprise. – [Rhett] Is pretzel hater – [Rhett] going to be a pretzel lover? – [Link] I’m going to give it a – [Link] I’m gonna give it an 80. – [Rhett] Look out. – [Stevie] Big Cup with Potato Chips. – [Rhett] Really? – [Link] Let’s see if this works. – [Link] A thinner crunch than the pretzel. – [Rhett] It was like a whole potato chip in there. – [Rhett] Mine felt like it was – [Rhett] a whole potato chip – [Rhett] that had been flattened. – [Link] Not as good as the pretzel – [Link] because not as much of a crunch. – [Link] It’s more of a break. – [Rhett] I feel like the potato of it all – [Rhett] detracts a teeny bit – [Rhett] from the chocolate experience, – [Rhett] but I still really like it. – [Rhett] I’m going to still give it a 79. – [Link] I’m going to give it a 49 – [Link] just because the pretzel – [Link] was that much better. – [Stevie] Stuffed with Pieces Big Cup. – [Rhett] With Reese’s Pieces? – [Link] Reese’s Pieces. – [Rhett] They made them big. – [Rhett] They made the Big Cups big, – [Rhett] and then they were like, – [Rhett] we have to fill these cups. – [Rhett] And they’ve been filling them – [Rhett] with things for years apparently – [Link] This one gets a little too sweet. – [Link] I’ve just discovered I’m more of a – [Link] saltified peanut butter guy – [Link] than a sweetafied peanut butter guy. – [Link] 55 – [Rhett] I like Reese’s Pieces, – [Rhett] but something about the combination – [Rhett] is making both of them worse – [Rhett] than they would be on their own. – [Rhett] Not a lot of synergy here. – [Rhett] Still tasty. 65. – [Stevie] And that concludes the Big Cup category. ((Laughing)) – [Stevie] Now it’s time for the – [Stevie] Small Cup category. – [Link] This is, I think, going to be my jam. – [Rhett] I like small cups too. – [Link] more chocolate – [Link] to the peanut butter ratio. – [Rhett] All cups don’t have to be big. – [Stevie] Starting with – [Stevie] Thins Milk Chocolate. – [Rhett] I’m more of an ass man anyway. – [Link] I don’t like the milk chocolate. – [Link] I can tell it’s like an imitation Reese’s – [Link] 31. – [Rhett] I don’t understand this one. – [Rhett] I still like it more – [Rhett] than not liking it though. – [Rhett] 51 – [Stevie] Thins Dark Chocolate. – [Link] Okay, we know the drill. – [Link] 44. – [Rhett] 49. – [Stevie] Thins White Creme – [Link] I’m hitting a bit of a wall. – [Rhett] Thins White Creme. – [Rhett] Yeah, that was me around 17, 18 – [Rhett] It’s so thin. – [Link] That’s not great. – [Link] 29 – [Rhett] 34. – [Link] Glad to have so many palate cleansers. – [Link] I kind of need all of them. – [Rhett] I’m not going bread – [Rhett] that seems too intense. – [Link] I have so much sugar – [Link] in my stomach – [Stevie] Milk Chocolate Miniatures. – [Rhett] Now, first of all, – [Rhett] you have a thing about these. – [Rhett] You really like these ratios. – [Link] These are classic. – [Link] Except not the milk chocolate. – [Rhett] I got a lot of your finger in that one. – [Rhett] It is nice though. – [Link] 54. – [Rhett] That’s pretty good. – [Rhett] 74 – [Stevie] White Chocolate Miniatures. – [Link] I don’t even want to taste it. – [Rhett] That’s the best – [Rhett] white chocolate one so far. – [Rhett] I don’t know why. – [Link] Because it’s so much white chocolate. – [Rhett] Because I got more peanut butter – [Rhett] or more white chocolate? – [Link] White chocolate. – [Link] You’re just bored with chocolate. – [Rhett] 56. – [Link] 19. – [Stevie] Dark Chocolate Miniatures. – [Link] Is that your finger? – [Link] Okay. – [Rhett] This one feels like – [Rhett] a different dark chocolate – [Rhett] than the Thins. – [Link] 46. – [Rhett] Because it’s a little bit better. – [Rhett] 60 – [Stevie] Reese’s Puffs Cereal – [Stevie] Milk Chocolate Miniatures. – [Rhett] Oh, they can get the cereal – [Rhett] into the miniatures? – [Link] They also have mini – [Link] Reese’s cereal now. – [Link] Which I do recommend. – [Rhett] When you had this much sugar, – [Rhett] the appetite goes down. – [Rhett] And so you have to – [Rhett] keep moving your scale, – [Rhett] so that you don’t overrate the things – [Rhett] at the beginning – [Rhett] because right now I’m like, – [Rhett] you know, I don’t want this anymore. – [Link] I’m trying to take all that into account. – [Link] 68 – [Rhett] Because I remember liking – [Rhett] this combination a moment ago. – [Rhett] 74. – [Link] You got to eat some bread, man. – [Link] That’ll help. – [Stevie] Zero Sugar Miniatures. – [Link] Oh, this could be awesome. ((Laughing)) – [Link] It’s not nearly as bad – [Link] as I thought it was going to be. – [Rhett] but it feels like – [Rhett] there’s something missing. – [Link] You know what? – [Rhett] It is way better – [Rhett] than I thought it was going to be. – [Rhett] I think I actively like it. – [Rhett] 54 – [Link] 36. – [Stevie] Reese’s with Pretzels Miniatures. – [Link] Okay, the sleeper is back – [Link] in a small form. – [Rhett] Oh. – [Link] I’m such a fan of this. – [Link] I’m going to give it a 77. – [Rhett] 81 – [Stevie] Minis Milk Chocolate Unwrapped. – [Link] Come on, now. – [Rhett] Well, they’ve all been unwrapped. – [Rhett] What are you talking about? – [Link] No, they’re usually wrapped. – [Link] These smaller ones. – [Rhett] Oh, you’re saying that – [Rhett] these just come loose in a bag. – [Link] Yeah. You just you can just, like, – [Link] dump them all in the bag. – [Link] These are better, I believe, – [Link] than the minis – [Link] What are the smaller cups called? – [Link] These are the minis. – [Stevie] Miniatures. – [Rhett] I need the wrapping. – [Rhett] I need the wrapping. – [Rhett] You like these the best? – [Link] This is so good because – [Link] I don’t debate – [Link] whether I should eat half of it – [Link] or all of it, – [Rhett] which is interesting – [Rhett] because I ate half of it. – [Link] Listen, that is almost tops right there. – [Link] I give that a 93. – [Link] You can eat two at once. – [Link] And even though I’m hurting, – [Link] I’m happy. – [Link] Counting my blessings. – [Rhett] I don’t think there’s enough – [Rhett] I don’t think there’s – [Rhett] enough peanut butter. – [Rhett] I mean, I like it. – [Rhett] I’ll give it 82. – [Stevie] And that concludes the – [Stevie] Small Cups category. – [Stevie] Our final category of the day is Non-Cups, – [Stevie] starting with – [Stevie] Fast Break Milk Chocolate – [Stevie] Peanut Butter Candy Bars. – [Link] Okay, Fast Break. – [Link] Oh, look, we got a nice cross section. – [Link] Can you rotate it so I can still bite it – [Link] as if it were, – [Link] no not, there we go. ((Laughing)) – [Rhett] Would you say there’s nougat in this? – [Link] There’s nougat. – [Link] There’s a nougat bed in the bottom. – [Rhett] I don’t know if nougat – [Rhett] has a home here – [Rhett] I’ve turned nougat away many times. – [Rhett] Every time it comes to my door – [Rhett] during a storm. – [Rhett] I’m like, nougat, – [Rhett] I don’t believe you have a home here. – [Link] Nougat is the hardest – [Link] soft thing you can eat. – [Rhett] What’s hard about it? – [Link] It’s soft, – [Link] but it’s the hardest soft thing – [Link] you can eat. – [Rhett] I can think of harder soft things – [Rhett] like a Tootsie Roll is harder – [Rhett] but still soft – [Rhett] 29 – [Link] I’m going to give it a 99. ((Laughing)) – [Link] It is the softest candy bar – [Link] you can have. – [Rhett] That’s weird. – [Link] It’s such a favorite candy bar. – [Stevie] I’ll remind the Mythical Beasts. – [Stevie] This is why at the end – [Stevie] we also reveal Rhett’s favorite – [Stevie] and Link’s favorite. – [Link] It’s so good. It’s the salt. – [Link] It’s the hardest soft candy bar – [Link] you’ll ever eat. – [Stevie] Okay, let’s move on to – [Stevie] Take 5 Chocolate Peanut Butter – [Stevie] Candy Bars. – [Link] Tell me what’s in this. – [Link] I know there’s like pretzels in there – [Rhett] Pretzel taste comes through – [Rhett] real strong on this. – [Rhett] I would expect you to not like that, – [Rhett] because you definitely taste, – [Rhett] it’s pretzel forward. – [Link] It’s pretzels instead of nougat – [Rhett] Which is also – [Rhett] my nickname in high school. – [Link] Too much pretzel. – [Rhett] Too much pretzel, – [Rhett] which was also – [Rhett] No, I won’t do it a third time. – [Rhett] I’ll save it for another round. – [Link] It’s a good taste. – [Link] It’s just too much pretzel. – [Rhett] I don’t like it. 49. – [Link] 60. – [Stevie] Sticks Milk Chocolate – [Stevie] Peanut Butter Candy. – [Link] Sticks? Oh, this is those things. – [Link] Wafers. – [Rhett] You can’t slip a wafer – [Rhett] past these boys. – [Link] You get the nice, – [Link] tasteless crunch of a wafer. – [Rhett] Yeah. Wafers have never – [Rhett] done anything for anybody. – [Rhett] Wafers are the hardest. I mean – [Link] They’ve never done anything. – [Rhett] Wafers are the softest hard food – [Rhett] that you can eat. – [Link] Wafers are the most harmless food. – [Rhett] No, think about it. – [Rhett] They’re the softest, hard food – [Link] They are. – [Link] Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, that’s right. – [Rhett] Get it? – [Link] Yeah. – [Link] 75. – [Rhett] But you like it? – [Link] Oh, yeah. – [Link] Because it’s like a Nutter Butter – [Link] from Little Debbie. – [Rhett] I don’t think. – [Rhett] I think wafers are – [Rhett] a “wafs” of “spafs” – [Rhett] 38. – [Stevie] Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter – [Stevie] XL Candy Bars. – [Link] Never had this. – [Link] Oh, this is – [Rhett] This is a piece of one – [Link] It’s in like little cubes. – [Rhett] It’s a candy bar that’s basically just – [Link] For rich people. – [Rhett] Cups. ((Laughing)) – [Rhett] Yeah. I was definitely thinking – [Rhett] for rich people. – [Link] I love the ratio. – [Link] I love the softness. – [Rhett] You really like high chocolate ratios. – [Rhett] One of the things I’m observing. – [Link] I’m going to give it a – [Link] 70. – [Rhett] 70? – [Rhett] I don’t like the chocolate ratio – [Rhett] on this one – [Rhett] but it’s better than not good. – [Rhett] 62 – [Stevie] Nutrageous Milk Chocolate – [Stevie] Peanut Butter Candy Bars. – [Link] This one’s begging for a 69 ((Laughing)) – [Link] Nutrageous. So there is a – [Link] a column of peanut butter in the middle – [Link] surrounded by nuts – [Link] and then surrounded – [Link] by chocolate in it. – [Link] It looks. – [Rhett] There’s nougat too. – [Link] Like a floating dookie log. – [Rhett] There’s nougat – [Rhett] or maybe there’s caramel? – [Rhett] There’s something sticking around – [Link] It’s caramel. – [Link] 48. – [Rhett] I thought you were going to say – [Link] 69. – [Link] I wanted to. – [Rhett] 69. – [Stevie] Reese’s Pieces. – [Link] What? That’s it? – [Link] All of a sudden – [Link] we’re eating Reese’s Pieces? – [Stevie] That’s where we are. – [Rhett] How did we get here? I wonder. – [Rhett] It’s very interesting to taste these – [Rhett] in the context of tasting Reese’s, – [Rhett] because I’ll get Reese’s Pieces – [Rhett] at the movie theater, – [Rhett] and they work – [Rhett] because I’m eating popcorn – [Rhett] and drinking Diet Coke – [Rhett] at the same time. – [Rhett] But they’re not good in the context – [Rhett] of eating other Reese’s stuff – [Link] On this scale. In this session, – [Link] I’m giving it a 28. – [Rhett] I don’t feel like I could do that, – [Rhett] but I feel like as low – [Rhett] as I could go – [Rhett] is a 50. – [Rhett] And that’s shocking to me. – [Stevie] Mini Reese’s Pieces. – [Link] I thought we were done. – [Rhett] These are for ET’s baby. ((Laughing)) – [Link] I’m gonna give it a 27. – [Rhett] There’s more candy per peanut butter. – [Rhett] Which makes it not as good – [Rhett] 42 – [Stevie] That concludes the Non-Cup category – [Stevie] You have now tasted every – [Stevie] Reese’s candy variety – [Stevie] available, and your scores will now – [Stevie] tabulated, so that you may more – [Stevie] closely judge your top 4 flavors – [Stevie] and crown the winner – [Stevie] Reese’s royalty – [Rhett] Before we reveal our top four. – [Rhett] Do you know what we did? – [Rhett] We took Stevie to Halloween Horror Nights, – [Rhett] and you and her were so scared. – [Link] Stevie, you had never been in a horror maze. – [Stevie] Never, ever. – [Rhett] It showed. – [Link] I had, but I don’t like them. – [Link] And he freaking loves them. – [Rhett] I tried to help all I could. – [Link] You can watch us be scared – [Link] again and again and again and again. – [Link] And also eat some amazingly – [Link] horrified themed Universal food. – [Link] So go to Mythicalsociety.com – [Link] right now but hey here’s a little trailer. – [Rhett] Stevie, what do you think – [Rhett] about being scared? – [Stevie] I am so scared – [Stevie] of being scared ((Music)) – [Stevie] Oh my God. I did not see him – [Stevie] Yours are so much bigger. – [Stevie] than mine. – [Rhett] We’re boys. – [Link] We’re boys. – [Rhett] Link? – [Stevie] Link. – [Stevie] Link – [Rhett] Looks like fun – [Rhett] Mythicalsociety.com – [Link] It was kind of like so unfun – [Link] it became fun. – [Link] I’m sure you’ll love watching – [Rhett] I had a great time. All right. – [Stevie] Okay, so before I reveal – [Stevie] your collective top four, – [Stevie] your individual favorites are – [Stevie] Rhett, Milk Chocolate. So – [Rhett] Original. – [Link] Which we kept harping on milk chocolate. – [Link] But that’s just the original. – [Rhett] The Creamy Milk Chocolate – [Rhett] wasn’t gonna get through me. – [Rhett] That was different. – [Stevie] And, Link, yours was Fast Break – [Stevie] Milk Chocolate – [Stevie] Peanut Butter Candy Bars. – [Link] The softest hard bar on the planet. – [Stevie] Is that a surprise to you? – [Link] To me? No. – [Stevie] Oh, no. You knew you liked this bar. – [Link] I knew that I love this bar. – [Stevie] Oh, okay. So your least favorite, – [Stevie] of course, was the – [Stevie] Plant Based Oat Chocolate Confection – [Stevie] But in no particular order. – [Stevie] Here are your top four favorites. – [Stevie] Big Cup with Reese’s Puffs, – [Stevie] Reese’s Puffs Cereal Milk Chocolate. – [Stevie] Minis Milk Chocolate Unwrapped – [Stevie] Milk Chocolate Original – [Stevie] and Big Cup with Pretzels. – [Rhett] So, a little difference of opinion here. – [Link] Let’s start with Big Cups – [Link] and then I think we should talk – [Link] about these two together. – [Link] Talk about these two together. – [Rhett] Which Big Cup is better? – [Link] I love both of these Big Cups. – [Link] We were pretty much in agreement. – [Link] It’s just more of a question of – [Link] is the fact that – [Link] I was so surprised by the pretzel. – [Rhett] Surprised by the pretzel. – [Rhett] Oh, it’s double wrapped. – [Rhett] Oh, it’s triple wrapped. – [Rhett] No, it’s quadruple wrapped. – [Rhett] No it’s five, six, seven, eight, – [Rhett] Nine, ten. – [Rhett] I got ten wrappers! – [Link] Well, hold on. – [Link] But this one literally has one wrapper. – [Link] All right. So – [Rhett] I’m so excited about that. – [Link] Here is your pretzel – [Link] and there is your Puff. – [Link] Open the door and eat some stuff. – [Link] For such a tall daddy, – [Link] it’s nice to be filled up – [Link] with something else, – [Link] something airy. – [Link] It doesn’t add any flavor, though. – [Rhett] I like Puffs less. – [Link] So much crunch. – [Rhett] Pretzels real solid. – [Rhett] The salt, man. – [Link] So – [Rhett] The salt men. – [Link] We’re saying that the pretzels – [Link] are better than the Reese’s Puffs. – [Rhett] Significantly better side by side. – [Rhett] Now you love the ratio of these. – [Rhett] Let me give them a chance. – [Rhett] Let me give them a chance. – [Rhett] No wrappers. – [Rhett] Ten wrappers. – [Link] And I know you have – [Link] a lot of fun with wrappers. – [Rhett] What is the difference – [Rhett] between Stagecoach and Coachella? ((Laughing)) – [Link] Not anymore. – [Rhett] There’s wrappers – [Rhett] at Stagecoach. – [Link] I’m sure. – [Link] Why are we talking about this? – [Rhett] Because of my awesome joke. – [Link] I love, okay, yeah. – [Link] I love these better, man. – [Link] They’re just, they’re less trouble – [Link] and they’re so tempting. – [Link] They’re just like, – [Link] gobble, gobble, gobble. – [Rhett] The peanut butter. – [Rhett] I’m just telling you, man. – [Rhett] The peanut butter gets lost. – [Rhett] You just like chocolate. – [Rhett] As a peanut butter boy. – [Link] Don’t yell at me. – [Rhett] I’m disappointed in you. – [Rhett] You can’t taste the peanut butter. – [Rhett] I just had a whole one and – [Rhett] I could barely tell that – [Rhett] there was peanut butter there. – [Link] Do you like this better – [Link] than the Reese big puff? – [Rhett] Where’s the pretzel one? – [Link] You don’t need to taste the pretzel one – [Rhett] I need to know. – [Rhett] Oh, do I like, I like the big puff – [Rhett] better than those for sure. – [Rhett] The question is, do I like the big puff – [Rhett] better than the original? – [Rhett] I don’t know, maybe – [Link] I’ll go with that. – [Rhett] Did I just eat yours? – [Link] Yes. – [Link] I’m putting the original – [Link] down below all three of these. – [Rhett] Okay. – [Rhett] I don’t like the Big Puff Reese’s Puffs. – [Rhett] I tasted that again – [Rhett] and it’s not good. – [Link] I’m willing to say – [Link] that I’m not being nostalgic. – [Link] All right. So if you give me – [Link] this pretzel wherever I want it. – [Link] I’ll let you place the other two, – [Link] and I’ll let you place them first. – [Rhett] Well, I’ll tell you – [Rhett] before you place it. – [Link] Okay. – [Rhett] Then, in my opinion – [Link] Yeah? – [Rhett] The pretzel is the best one. – [Link] All right. Yeah. – [Rhett] I think the pretzel is – [Rhett] so unexpected, and the salt – [Link] So we’re going to. – [Rhett] makes it even better than the original. – [Link] We’re going to put original there, – [Link] and then we’re going to put – [Link] I’m going to put this here, – [Rhett] But then – [Link] You’re going to put this here – [Link] and we’re just not going to argue about it – [Link] because it’s third, who really cares? – [Rhett] And what we’re saying, – [Rhett] to the surprise of – [Link] Everybody. – [Rhett] people everywhere. – [Link] The Reese’s Pretzels Big Cup is – [Link] whatever we’re calling the winner. – [Rhett] The best Reese’s. – [Stevie] Reese’s Royalty. – [Rhett] Reese’s Royalty. – [Rhett] That’s almost as scary as a pumpkin. – [Link] Thanks for subscribing – [Link] and clicking that bell. – [Link] Remember, tomorrow – [Link] our special Halloween episodes. – [Link] Come on back. – [Rhett] You know what time it is. – [Nick] My name’s Nick, – [Nick] and this is my dad, Alexander. – [Nick] We’re in Madison, Wisconsin, – [Alexander] and we’re about to do – [Alexander] Gut Check: Reese’s Edition – [Nick] And it’s time. – [Nick] To spin the Wheel of Mythicality – [Rhett] Well, shoot, – [Rhett] we didn’t even need to do it. – [Link] You’re in for it. – [Rhett] Click the top link to – [Rhett] watch us discover the ten worst – [Rhett] rated businesses on Google – [Rhett] and Good Mythical More – [Link] And to find out where – [Link] the Wheel of Mythicality is going to land. – [Rhett] We went to Halloween Horror Nights – [Rhett] with Stevie. You can watch it now – [Rhett] available for 1st, 2nd – [Rhett] and 3rd degree members – [Rhett] of the Mythical Society, – [Rhett] Mythicalsociety.com “