GMMore 2989: We Rank Every Kind Of Soup

GMMore 2989: We Rank Every Kind Of Soup thumbnail

Channel: Good Mythical More

YouTube Video ID: RH8JCfEXzDo

Episode Post Date: February 26, 2026

Episode Number: 2989

Transcript

We're making a soup tier list.
Welcome to Good Mythical More.
Soup lovers everywhere.
Are tearing up.
Wow.
We're gonna tear up over these soups.
Tears are going right into their soups.
Would you consider yourself a soup lover?
Not.
Me neither.
I'm not a soup lover.
I'm a soup accepter.
I'll accept it.
Oh yeah.
I'm never.
It's very rare that I get excited about soup.
The only there is, there are two soups on
here that I get legitimately excited about.
Oh, one is a true app and
one is a meal in itself.
But are we assuming like these are
the best versions of these things?
Soups?
Sure.
This is is like you have gone to the
place where this is their specialty.
This is the best soup they got.
Yeah.
'cause there's a lot of bad.
You know, I'm just saying I'm not
gonna get that excited about soup.
I don't know what gazpacho is, but is that,
how's that different than tomato soup?
It's cold.
Oh, well that's D. I like to either eat or
drink, not both soup, you know what I mean?
I wanna know I'm eating or I'm drinking.
So you don't like mcha ball soup
because you have to eat the balls?
Uh, that's not really what I meant.
What I meant was something
that's not a liquid or a solid.
I is something I like if
I'm drinking, I'm drinking.
If I'm eating, I'm eating.
But also these are like, you're not a
meal soup guy, you're is that, you know?
So it's like this is an appetizer.
Only when I'm sick.
I went through sick.
I just remember I went through a soup era.
When was this?
In grade school.
Okay.
I got my mom.
My mom bought me a thermos.
A thermos.
I remember this.
Remember my Thermos era,
and it was a big thermos.
Your suit would still be steaming as
soon as it lunch rolled around because
I got a really good thermos and it
had like glass double insulation.
It had glass inside of it.
Yes.
Couldn't drop it.
I dropped it and I broke it
and I broke all the glass in it
and everything became gazpacho.
I don't know, it's not like my mom was
gonna whip me or something, but like.
I was devastated.
You should have been.
I was.
I remember being devastated.
And this was before your parents
would buy you a new thing.
Like in today's modern world, you
break something, your parents are
like, oh, and they buy it In our
world, you broke your glass thermos.
You never got a new one.
Yeah, I mean, I guess
that's what I was so upset.
It was like that was your chance.
Soup times over liny poo and there would
be leftovers in there that would stay warm.
Oh man.
Like my favorite thing, my
favorite meal was Hamburger Helper.
Yeah.
And it's tough to see that come
out of a thermos and like the
cheeseburger hamburger helper.
Yeah, it gross.
I always looked away while
you were pour it out.
It was so warm and so nice and
I would eat it out of the thing.
Yeah, that the best version of
a soup, that hamburger helper.
Yeah.
He's not a soup at all.
Um, I would have that in there.
So my soup era.
Really ham on a hamburger helper.
I'm trying to think what
else I would put in there.
You'd be over there eating that hot steamy
hamburger helper and I'd have a hot dog
sandwich that was as cold as it was outside.
You know, it was just like the
tinfoil that my mom had wrapped
it in had had a big crack in it.
Yeah, she'd also wrap me up a pb and
j and like all of the jelly would like
soak into that half of the sandwich.
That's pretty good though.
And it would become this
like floppy heavy thing.
I love that wasn't in a thermostat.
Maybe we should rank a soup.
Gazpacho.
D. Drag it.
Sure I don't.
A cold soup, why are you doing it?
Right.
Tomato.
And with a grilled cheese sandwich.
Well, there's no grilled cheese here.
This is just a soup.
If it's just a soup, it's probably C.
I'll accept B if you really wanna push it.
I'm not gonna push hard on
anything here except two of them.
Um.
Broccoli cheddar is got so much cheese
in it and you feel like you're doing
something healthy because you get
broccoli, but you know you're not.
Um, but I'm just gonna say that I
think broccoli cheddar is a at or soup.
Yeah.
On.
And when you're talking
about, have you had it lately?
Like, okay, what?
What?
No.
What to you is the lately A tier?
Well, 'cause not a Panera.
That's the thing.
Like I remember that being like a
signature Panera thing and mm-hmm.
I remember the first time I had it I was
like, cheese and then I had it again and
I was like, chemical or, yeah, yeah, yeah.
They changed it, you know, they changed it.
So it's like, like society changed.
Broccoli, cheddar.
I didn't, Panera did like maybe.
I dunno.
I think Panera did.
I mean, it's just hard.
It's hard.
Chicken noodle.
Oh, chicken noodle is, it's a classic.
It's a good taste, but it's, but
it makes me think about being sick.
It makes me think about being sick.
CC for sick, C below tomato,
I would swap those two.
Okay.
I'm not gonna argue.
Uh, now you're holding back on your feet.
I will, I will enjoy
something I've just seen now.
I will enjoy a lobster bisque
at our nice restaurant.
I like a lobster biscuits.
If there's a lobster bisque,
I'm putting it in the rotation.
Let's go.
A, we're not.
That's a a. Yeah.
I'm not gonna s here anything until
we've got this thing more laid out.
Well, okay.
I got, I'm kind, I'm, I'm, I'm, I'm, uh, I
got two going straight to S here, brother.
Oh, you do?
We'll save those men.
That's a D for me.
Don't like it.
What is it even?
It's, it's like vegetables and
like, it's like leftover soup.
Yeah, but it's, but it has a noodle in it.
Yeah, it has a weird noodle.
It shouldn't have a noodle.
It's like a vegetable soup, but
with a noodle that I don't like.
And the beans are really big.
I don't like that.
You know, people eat a lot of
soup and they eat a lot of canned
soup, but now they're finding out.
That all the soups have the lining in them.
You know, like most of those
soups, like people, I don't know.
They knew that there was some stuff that
wasn't great about canned stuff and now
I don't know what, I don't know what the
updated stuff is, but stuff, stuff, stuff.
You talking about leach leaching, there's
that, but then all of these, a lot
of these cans are lined with plastic.
It's like the P, isn't that the PFA?
Yeah.
And it's the forever chemical.
So that, oh, that reminds me.
Soup is forever in you.
I had another era once my thermos broke
and it was called the chunky soup era.
Yeah, I remember that as well.
And it was, it was a flip top, peel
away thing and it, but the outside.
It felt like plastic on the outside, and
sometimes I would, once I got deep into
that era, I started getting dent, more
stew dent, more dti, more beef stew.
And that's hard, man.
And if you don't heat that stuff up enough,
it's got these like, like fat chunks in it.
Oh, you know how like you gotta get it hot?
You can do, you can do these like,
uh, vision boards, not vision
boards or like look, look books.
Yeah.
Where it's just like things that
are like represent you in that era.
There's like definitely a link.
Yeah.
That there's like a thing of chunky soup.
Yeah.
And then there's soup, like a pogo ball.
Right.
And like a ww f. Yep.
Action Figure.
Yeah, man.
Yep.
Those are the days.
Uh, Converse All Stars Knee highs,
not Kneehigh, it just folded over.
Hold on.
But they, they called 'em knee highs.
Well, no, there are some that went up.
But you folded them,
went, you folded 'em over.
They weren't knee highs.
They could have been knee highs.
They weren't called knee highs.
They were, there was another thing
that would go to your knee, but
that girls would wear that wear.
They were called knee
highs where we come from.
Mine just folded over.
I feel like most of what we've left, I
don't have a connection to ZA Ball suit.
The first time I had it was on this show.
I gotta see that good.
A good, I don't disagree with that, but
there, that's what I mean is like it's a
big, you gotta have a good matza ball soup.
You're like, but it's in the
sick category a little bit.
I think it's, I think it's
right next to chicken noodle.
I chicken noodle.
Think it beats.
Whoa, whoa, whoa.
It's worse than chicken noodle.
What?
Have you had a good one.
Here's why.
Disagree.
The ball.
Why are the balls so big?
They don't have to be.
No.
The ball are always don't be.
And you know what?
They don't have to be, the only
thing in it is just soggy bread.
There's nothing.
No.
Oftentimes it is like you take the noodles
out of chicken noodle and you still have
the shredded chicken and the vegetables and
all that, but that ball is just wet bread.
But a lot of people, and me
included, like wet bread.
You don't like wet bread.
So I think that you might
have to just, which is odd.
I felt aside, like wet bread holes
in your, he doesn't like amisu.
The mussies dessert.
I don't like soggy bread.
He complains about cake being too
dry and matza balls being too wet.
Too What?
Too big?
How?
How do you satisfy this man?
I think we gotta put it at B here.
Now.
Split pea.
You love split pea.
Oh God.
S. Okay.
We eat, we each, we each get a couple
of S tiers without any argument.
Yep.
That's my one right there.
And split.
No.
Tell us about split pea.
Why is it so good for you?
And when did you discover it?
Was it in your elementary school?
No.
Yeah.
No.
This is as a complete adult.
Peas are the mussies vegetable.
That's why.
What's that?
Um, green.
What pea?
What's the split pea?
The sour peas in the can.
That's what I love.
Place.
Anderson's.
Yeah.
And it's gone.
Yeah.
Oh, it's gone.
It's gone.
I didn't know about it.
I mean, did you have it before?
Never had it.
Oh.
But we, uh, Christy makes it at home.
Yeah.
After, um, she puts ham in right Thanksgiving
because she takes the honey baked ham.
Ooh.
Or the ham.
The ham that I used to burn.
She would take pieces of that.
She would take the parts that weren't
burned and she would put that in the
split pea soup, and it's just great.
That is.
You know what?
I'm in complete agreement with
this being S tier because.
It's thick.
There's something about the
combination of those flavors.
Yeah.
That it just hits so hard and
it's unique in its entity.
Let's talk about clam chowder for a moment.
Love it.
New England, it's, it's very good.
I think it's a tier.
Yeah.
Now this is New England.
This is not, they don't have
the other one, the red one.
Manhattan style.
I don't want that.
Which, yeah.
Why are we doing that?
This?
Yeah, that.
I love some clam chowder.
Especially those little hle.
H what?
What is it?
Hexagon.
Oh yeah, the little crackers.
Are they hexagons or octagons?
They're puffy.
I'll say that.
Mm-hmm.
Those are nice.
And if you go to a, why they,
why do they go with clam chowder?
That's my question.
I don't.
And why does it work at a steak restaurant?
I don't know.
Well, usually it's a, usually, I mean,
they, I've been to a couple of steak
restaurants they have, but it's usually
a steak restaurant that also has a good
lobster, which most steak steak places do.
Now you can get a bad clam chowder
too, and when you get a bad one,
it's the worst thing you can eat.
But these are all the best.
But this, if this is the best.
Oh yeah.
If the cream, it's eight.
Like if the cream is sour gumbo.
A good gumbo.
I'm still gonna say B if
you got the best gumbo.
Yeah.
Dude, we are approaching chili
territory to give you a little uh,
right hint as where I'm going here.
Yeah.
But, um, 'cause it what It's got what?
It's got that an dey sausage in it.
Mm-hmm.
That's good.
Yeah, dude, it's so good.
And it's so regional.
It's a treat.
I think it's at least a, here.
I was gonna say B, so we're gonna have to
stick with a. Now chicken and dumplings
is a very North Carolina thing like,
but they serve that at our cafeteria.
I do not consider it a soup though.
It's like between a soup
and a chicken pot pie.
But is that, I mean, we would eat it.
Is it super regional?
Like when we would eat it, we
would not eat it on in a bowl.
We would eat it on a plate.
They put it in, well, they put it in the.
The part of the tray that kind of catches
it all the tray at like the cafeteria.
Yeah.
I, I'm, I'm fine with beef for that.
Did you ever, because I
don't consider it a soup.
Did you eat it at school?
No.
You never got school lunch?
Never got it.
I was just suspicious of, wow, you messed up.
You missed so many great guys.
What was going on back there?
You missed so many great things.
Yeah, chicken and dumplings.
Let's just put it at b. Okay.
I mean, something's gotta go down.
It's like a nice little chicken shelf.
Are you trying to move chili to S here?
Because 1000% I think we got to if a, a,
the best chili, like when I get home, and
I mean most of the time we would do takeout
or I'll just do like a really light dinner
that I like, make myself or whatever.
Every once in a while, just chili on the pot.
I get home and I know it as soon as I
walk in and she's like, I made chili.
And I'm just like, I know I'm
about to go crazy on this chili.
'cause she also makes cornbread
put, put the cornbread.
Oh yeah.
In the bowl.
Put the chili on top of it so it gets lost.
They make different chili
and then I find it again.
They, they, um, they make the same cornbread,
they use the same recipe, which is great.
They being our wives.
Yeah.
Um, the chill.
I love tea or chili.
Yeah, chili.
And again, it can be done
a couple of different ways.
Jessie has a little dark chocolate
in her chili that gives it this like
sweetness that I absolutely love.
It's a little bit spicy.
It's got the, we gotta do the beans.
It's a full meal.
That's, that's why I
think it's so incredible.
I'm kind of getting caught up on, um.
Baked potato versus broccoli cheddar.
'cause I think baked potato is better
than broccoli cheddar, but it's not
as good for you as broccoli cheddar.
Okay, fine.
C it put it at C now It is good though
this, this may be controversial.
I think broccoli cheddar needs to
move down to b. I agree with that.
Okay.
I'm, I am just not the
biggest fan of miso soup.
I can, I just, can I
just come out and say it?
I, you can like, you don't like the,
like you don't like the taste of it.
Well, let me, you know me.
I'm not gonna say anything
and I'm going to eat it all.
Like, so you take me to a restaurant,
a Japanese hibachi, they bring the miso
soup because it's part of the thing.
I'm gonna eat it and I'm going to enjoy it.
Mm-hmm.
Somewhat.
Okay.
But this is a soup tier list and I'm
just, there's just something about it.
The thing I really don't like is when
they put miso on other things, like Wow.
Yeah, I, there's something about miso
seasoning on like a meat, like a miso salmon.
That I'm always like, ah, I
just wish this wasn't this.
Yeah, you don't like me, so that's okay.
Yeah.
You know, on my scale it's not
like liver, it's not repulsive.
It's just kind of like, ah,
this could be something else.
It's like the seasoning time.
Also not a huge fan of that.
You don't see time a lot.
I've started to.
Be okay with miso soup.
Like I can, I can drink a whole
bowl of it now, Uhhuh, but, um,
a year ago I wouldn't touch it.
So that puts it at d for me.
I do like that it's a soup that you can
pick up and drink without using a spoon.
And it's some, it's like acceptable.
Yeah, I like that.
That's fun about it.
A lot of people say that it's an aphrodisiac.
I'm a big fan of drinking.
So from the bowl.
Yeah.
Yeah, yeah.
Have you not heard of the, the
famous saying, miso horny, uh.
God, you dumb black bean.
Talk about it.
The famous saying, two live crew.
Uh, hold on.
Okay, go.
Black Bean.
Two live crew was the legit guys.
Black bean.
There's more sighing that's happening.
Link would've had that on his vision
board, his his look book Pogo Ball.
No, I wouldn't.
Two live crew.
Black bean is in the big
potato category for me.
I don't understand.
I, I like black beans.
Yeah.
And sometimes this is so
unexciting, but what is that?
And this is a bean guy saying this.
Yeah.
I don't think we need to unbe.
I Beans C tier.
Chicken tortilla.
Chicken tortilla.
I If it's good.
We had an era where that was me.
It's almost a chilling, but I
think it can, I'm kind of over it.
I don't know.
Christy makes a really good chicken to
think about how good it can be though.
And it can be really the best.
I think it's a tier when it's the best.
'cause it's so meal unified.
It's such a meal.
Okay.
Alright.
Yeah, I'm coming around.
I had, um, Porto's had a caldo
deez, like, like beef soup special.
And I'm, I don't get, I don't get soup.
Soup is not, you don't go
to Porto's and get soup?
No, I've never done it.
I'm telling you.
Well, they do everything great.
What is it called again?
It's, it's basically beef
soup is what it translates to.
But caldo de re.
And it's like a, it's like a,
it's, it's kind of tortillas.
Just a st st st. But
it's like more of a beef.
Yeah.
Is it gravy consistency?
No, it's, it's, is it
like vie like enti more?
No, no.
It, it's not a stewy, it's, it's more of a
it consistency of like a, a chicken noodle
or a chicken soup, but it's with beef.
Oof.
Lord.
Okay.
Well we've left What I assume
is your, your favorite.
I think that this last one, if
there is a double S tier, then there
shouldn't be because that's not fair.
French onion soup, man.
What a start to a meal.
What?
A start to a meal.
Drag it up there.
I mean, just think about it.
Cheese is great, first of all,
and then the way that it's like
if the, if you do it right.
It's got the, that layer,
it's got the soggy bread.
Ooh.
And the bread is actually stale
bread that has been used again.
And there's just something
beautiful about that.
Now, you started off this more saying
that you weren't a real soup guy, and
I found that to be interesting because
you talk about french onion soup.
Yeah.
Pretty often.
Like if someone said like,
list rets favorite food.
In fact, in my last meal
I had french onion soup.
Well.
So, yeah.
So do you need to amend anything?
I guess I'm a soup guy.
Well, you're a french onion soup.
Yeah.
I'm a French onion soup guy and a chili guy.
Yeah.
And I'm a Split peaea guy and a chili guy.
That's the guys that we are.
Are we locked?
Are we locked in?
Is there anything we wanna shove?
I feel like this is a pretty good spread.
I mean, this is equal
opportunity across all tier.
Okay.
Locked.
Get your food fix on the
Mythical kitchen channel.
Now PEA's, putting hot PEA's, putting
cold PEA's, putting in the pot.
Nine days old.
Cock leaky bcal, leaky two days tall.

Discover more from Searchicality

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading